Make it Clear
The results of uncertainty are not difficult to find. Have you seen a product team circling, trying to iterate their way out of an endless spiral? Or received (or concocted!) feature requests that never discuss how theyโll make life better for anyone? In the absence of good information on the people or the problem, teams are tempted to choose quick but low quality solutions to fill the gap. Shockingly, this can work for products without serious consequences for being wrong. But when the stakes are higher, search out more information. As mentioned in Shift to Strategic Thinking, strategic design leaders deploy their user experience skills on the internal issues as well as the external. For tough questions, get as much certainty as possible. That path lies through spending time with the users and stakeholders. Donโt be tempted to skip this step. To reduce ambiguity and increase certainty, designer leaders engage in research, look for ways to retire cruft, and draw a compelling vision to rally support.
Engage in Research
Research peels back the veneer of the usersโ polished description of the current experience to get to the heart of why they are using the product. Kim Goodwin points to at least four things to pay attention to during this phase.
- The usersโ goals
- The usersโ environment
- The usersโ mental models
- The usersโ data models
This may seem counterintuitive or even overkill since people are so different. Shouldnโt we prefer a lighter method that relies more on subject matter expertise? Noโfor the simple reason that experts look at the product differently than most users. As you move through your research plan, users will begin to segment into patterns of behavior. They operate within a particular systemโthe one where this new product will live. Taking time up front to understand the system enables the design team to formulate a solution that accounts for the usersโ reality.
Knowing your users begins with spending time with them. Planning this time has three main steps.
- Decide what do you need to learn
- Look for people who use the product
- Write a set of interview questions to get at the objective in step 1
There isnโt time to unpack these, though chapter 6 of Designing for the Digital Age and this short article and course from the Interaction Design Foundation are good starting points if youโd like to dive in deeper.
Retire Cruft
During research, the team learns what is valuable to the user population and what isnโt. The Kano Model discussed in the previous article helps the product team map where various features stack up to each other. Particularly in late stage products or services, the amount of features added along the way begin to stack up, adding complexity to the product. This is known as โcruft.โ A distinguishing feature of cruft is that it sits there, unused and in the way. One way to spot cruft is through quantitative measures. Check the analytics to see which features people use and which they ignore. You can use the Kano Model to distinguish between the โcruftierโ features, separating them from the goldโthe excitement generators.
The Design leaderโs job is to unbury the users from this cruft. How many modernization efforts or spreadsheet replacement design projects focus solely on getting the new product out the door yet automate inefficiency? Often, the environment has changed. The spreadsheet or mainframe system were good solutions to different problems. Do not overlook the opportunity to look for cruft and eliminate it.
Draw a Compelling Vision
Once the team makes sense of the users and domain, the next step is to craft the design vision, sometimes referred to as the experience vision. Here, the team translates what theyโve learned into a clear point of view. Jared Spool compares this to planting a flag in the sand. Itโs far enough off to serve for 5-10 years, yet visible enough so that the team knows whether or not they are getting closer to it or further away. Spool mentions three qualities of these experience visions.
- The vision is research-based
- It spotlights the usersโ experience within the ecosystem
- They are shareable
Research snowballs forwardโproducing personas, then journey maps, next scenarios and requirements. These artifacts are the foundation for the design vision, a rich description of the future from the personasโ point of view. One of the best known public examples of this is the Apple Knowledge Navigator created in 1986 to guide Appleโs teams well into the 21st century. Though this was a highly produced vision, they donโt have to be. Cooper Design created this example which stitched together still photos, drawings of the interface, and a voice over to communicate an app concept. Another excellent example is this experience for a proposed hyperloop train system. One more example is Near Future Laboratoriesโ video describing โcurious ritualsโ to document a changing culture formed by digital devices. While not strictly an experience vision for a particular product, it does an excellent job showing the userโs real life with new technology in place.
These โflags in the sandโ function as a beacon, beckoning the product team forward in the same direction. Spool says, โBecause the flag is clearly visible, the team knows if every step they take brings them closer or farther awayโ (2018). The experience vision enables and inspires the team forward and helps stakeholders visualize the objective. The common aim rallies everyone to bring their talents to bear on solving the problem. Clarity carries the day.
Reflect
The Design practice gives the why of a product direction and clears uncertainty. Designers lead through clear, strategic thinking. However, the articulated problem from stakeholders is not always real. Use research to dig underneath the surface and learn about the people depending on this product. Excise the cruft. Now draw out the story of how things could be based on what you know. Design is a confident practice in an ambiguous world.
References
Goodwin, K. (2009). Designing for the digital age: How to create human-centered products and services. Wiley Pub.
Spool, J. M. (2018, June 14). The 3 Steps for Creating an Experience Vision. UX Articles by Center Centre. https://articles.centercentre.com/the-3-steps-for-creating-an-experience-vision/
Discover more from Bako Industries
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
